Discussion about this post

User's avatar
JasonT's avatar

Well written and thorough. Scripture teaches there was a global flood and an ark. It does not teach that the ark is preserved. Great if we find it, and totally unnecessary.

Joe Fanelli's avatar

My brother called me about this all excited. I told him to calm down. As a former Ancient Near Eastern archaeologist and historian (UC Berkeley, Judaic Studies undergraduate and Ancient Near Eastern History & Archaeology grad at Berkeley as well) and as a Christ follower it is refreshing to see believers reconcile scholarship and faith. One is not dependent on the other yet in the end one does not contradict the other.

I did two years of field work in Southern Pakistan (Indus Valley) looking for Dilmun lol. My focus was Middle Bronze Age to Early Iron Age Mesopotamia and we had hoped these two contemporaneous civilizations would show evidence of contact in this coastal Indus Valley city of Balakot. We went in with the same hope yet as you stated in the sentiment hope needs to meet the ground, we unfortunately found nothing. Both civilizations were sea faring and not all that far apart. We have yet to find hard evidence of their commerce.

My only publication was a UC Extension paper and talk at the UC Interdisciplinary Studies forum. That year it was the “Flood Myth”. The year before it was Velikovsky’s comet. My part was the archaeological evidence - and there is tons but all have been misdated thanks to Ms Kenyon and others. Even the thick alluvial clay layer evidence at Ur found by Sir Leonard Woolley was overlooked and misdated. The work of the great hydrologist Bobby Raikes was not finished or followed up on unfortunately as well

I left the field early, turning down a position at Yale, as the late 70’s Middle East was not so promising for excavations and with the change in regimes Pakistan was not the best area either. I also accepted a job managing production for Snoopy products that lead me to Hong Kong. Indiana Jones became James Bond…

I did have the privilege of studying with the best minds in the field at the time, including Kent Weeks, Richard Caplice, Ann Kilmer, Jacob Milgrom, Victor Gold, David Winston, Michal Artzy, Guitty Azarpay, and for a couple quarters, Emily Vermeule, and Samuel Noah Kramer.

I really enjoy following your Substack! Thank you for being true to your faith in Christ and love of the truth. Archaeology is not needed to prove the Word and if one’s faith is based on earthly evidence is it faith? “If they did not listen to Moses and the Prophets will not be persuaded even if someone rises from the dead…” or if the ark is found…

Thank you for your approach and heart towards the truth and clarity of scholarship. Evidence of the truth (Biblical narrative) buried out there in the deserts but remains in plain sight in the Bible if one had ears to hear.

13 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?